
A stick of chewing gum, offered by an undercover detective, closed two murders that haunted a city for more than forty years.
Story Snapshot
- DNA from a gum “ruse” matched evidence from two 1980s murder scenes.
- Mitchell Gaff pleaded guilty to killing Susan Vesey (1980) and Judith “Judy” Weaver (1984).
- A judge sentenced Gaff to 50 years to life in prison.
- Detectives say the methods used here are reshaping cold-case work.
Gum, DNA, and a long-delayed arrest
Everett detectives needed fresh DNA to test a long-held suspicion. They executed a simple plan. An undercover officer offered Mitchell Gaff a stick of gum. Gaff chewed it and tossed it. Detectives recovered it, then built a DNA profile from the saliva. That profile matched biological evidence saved from two murder scenes in Everett, Washington, from 1980 and 1984, cracking cases that had stalled for decades.
Those cases were the killings of 21-year-old Susan Vesey in 1980 and 42-year-old Judith “Judy” Weaver in 1984. Both women were raped and strangled, according to reporting that followed Gaff’s apprehension. The match did not stand alone. Detectives say the preserved evidence and case files aligned with the DNA findings, building a picture that pointed to one man. The gum ruse turned four decades of doubt into a clear investigative line.
The guilty pleas and the sentence
Mitchell Gaff pleaded guilty in Snohomish County Superior Court to two counts of first-degree murder. The Everett Police Department announced the pleas on April 16, 2026, confirming Gaff admitted to both killings tied to the old cases. The court then set sentencing. A judge later imposed a term of 50 years to life in prison, ensuring a 68-year-old man will likely die behind bars for what he did to Vesey and Weaver.
Killer’s chewing gum blows open 40-year-old murders, detective warns there may be more victims https://t.co/vcnaaD32bx #FoxNews
— Missing in the Midsouth (@Midsouthmissing) November 8, 2026
Media coverage described Gaff as a convicted rapist with a violent pattern and labeled the murders sadistic. Reporters detailed how he admitted to the rapes and strangulations during the legal process, with the DNA match as the anchor. The case shows how modern forensics, tight chain-of-custody records, and strategic police work can revive buried evidence and support a plea that brings certainty for families.
Why the gum ruse worked
Cold-case units across the country now pair smart field tactics with refined lab work. DNA testing can draw clear lines between a person and a crime when biological material survives. Here, detectives linked a fresh DNA sample to old evidence that had been collected and stored. That is the quiet hero of many cold cases: careful evidence preservation. Academic reviews call DNA in cold cases “game-changing” because it can resolve doubts years later and restore trust when handled with care.
Defense lawyers often question “cold hits” when a database search alone identifies a suspect. This case does not rest on a pure cold hit. Detectives targeted Gaff, obtained a fresh sample, and matched it to evidence from two scenes. Prosecutors then secured guilty pleas. That combination—targeted DNA and admissions—meets the common-sense standard most jurors and citizens share: if the science points to you and you confess, justice should move forward.
The broader lesson for public safety
Citizens expect the system to protect communities and honor victims, even when years pass. Police investigators delivered by sticking with the files, testing old evidence with new tools, and using a simple undercover tactic that stayed within legal bounds. The result was swift once the match came in: pleas, sentencing, and a measure of peace for two families. This is what justice looks like when the state keeps its promises and refuses to quit.
Some detectives now warn there could be more victims who never saw justice. That is not a claim about this sentence; it is a call to reopen files and test what can still be tested. The conservative view fits: back the cops, preserve evidence, fund labs, and keep violent offenders off the street. DNA does not replace good police work. It rewards it. The gum ruse was not a trick. It was persistence with purpose, and it saved the truth from being lost in time.
Sources:
foxnews.com, cbsnews.com, us.cnn.com, abcnews.com, wrganews.com








