Justice Flags Chilling Power Grab

Supreme Court building with grand columns and steps under a blue sky
Photo: lazyllama / Shutterstock

Justice Clarence Thomas warned that California’s rule turns private teachers into state messengers—and the Supreme Court let it stand for now.

Story Snapshot

  • California ties doctors’ license education to courses that must cover implicit bias.
  • Justice Thomas said this forces private speakers to carry the state’s viewpoint.
  • The Supreme Court declined review, leaving the Ninth Circuit ruling in place.
  • California says instructors can disagree while still covering the topic.

What the fight is really about: who owns the words

California requires physicians to complete continuing education that includes content on implicit bias to keep a medical license. The instruction often comes from private teachers and private accreditors, not state employees. Justice Clarence Thomas called that setup compelled private speech. He wrote that the First Amendment applies when government requires private speakers to communicate the government’s viewpoint. California says the rule only requires coverage of the topic, not personal endorsement, and teachers may say they disagree.

The United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit treated the covered courses as government speech. That move avoided free speech review. The court leaned on the state’s long role in regulating medicine, its control over qualifying course content, and the belief that the public would tie the message to the state program more than to each private instructor. The district court had dismissed the case on the same ground, and the Ninth Circuit affirmed.

Thomas and Alito’s warning: licensing is not a speech loophole

Justice Thomas, joined by Justice Samuel Alito, argued that labeling private lectures as government speech stretches the doctrine beyond its purpose. He said California “cannot regulate its way out of First Amendment scrutiny” by calling private instruction its own message. He also flagged that the mandate leaves instructors with “no choice” but to present the state’s view tying implicit bias to health disparities, which frames the teaching as a one-way message. The strength of that critique rests on the private setting of the speech.

California’s answer pushes back on compulsion. The state told the Court that instructors can say they doubt implicit bias exists and can explain they cover it only to comply with the rule. That is a material concession. It weakens the charge that the state demands ideological endorsement. Still, the command to include the topic at all attaches speech to licensure. For many readers who value limited government, that pressure looks like a speech condition with teeth, even if the state tolerates dissent while the box gets checked.

Why the Court’s “no” matters even though nothing was decided

The Supreme Court denied review, so there is no national rule here. The Ninth Circuit’s government-speech framing stands in the West. Doctors and teachers in that region must live with it unless a future case changes the landscape. Bloomberg Law reported the denial and flagged the broader stakes for training rules linked to diversity, equity, and inclusion themes. Denial of review does not bless the Ninth Circuit’s logic; it just leaves that result in place for now.

The path ahead splits in two. If future records show that California truly lets instructors critique the premise while meeting the coverage rule, courts may view this as a permissible content requirement in a licensing program. If, however, oversight or credit decisions punish dissenting presentation, the compelled-speech claim sharpens. The key facts will be who writes the words, who controls the message, and what happens when a private expert says, “Here is the state’s view—and here is why I disagree.”

The core test every state should meet

States can teach their own messages. That is government speech. But when a state points to a private person and says, “Say this,” the First Amendment alarm should sound. Common sense and American conservative values line up here: the government may set standards for skill and safety, but it should not draft private citizens as mouthpieces. California argues its system stays on the safe side by allowing open dissent. Thomas says the structure itself crosses the line. The country now waits for the right case with a full record to draw that line cleanly.

Sources:

foxnews.com, usatoday.com, news.bloomberglaw.com