Taxpayer Cash Vanishes Into Thin Air

Hand holding a disintegrating hundred dollar bill.
Photo: Shutterstock

Nearly 2,000 students who never set foot in a classroom walked away with $12.5 million in taxpayer money meant for real college kids in Minnesota.

Story Snapshot

  • The Department of Education says 1,834 “ghost students” in Minnesota received $12.5 million in federal grants and loans without ever attending class.
  • Minnesota State flagged more than 7,700 applications as fraudulent or suspicious during the 2024-2025 school year.
  • Minnesota State disputes the federal dollar figure, saying it never actually paid out money to the bogus accounts.
  • Real people, including named victims whose identities were stolen, are now stuck fighting loans they never took out.
  • Congress is pushing the No Aid for Ghost Students Act to force identity checks before any money goes out the door.

What Federal Officials Say Happened In Minnesota

Education Secretary Linda McMahon sent Minnesota Governor Tim Walz a letter in December laying out blunt numbers. It said 1,834 ghost students collected $12.5 million in taxpayer-funded aid. The letter claims these recipients were never identity-verified, often did not live in the United States, or simply did not exist as real people at all.

Minnesota State’s own system backs up the scale of the problem, even if it quarrels with the dollar amount. The college system flagged more than 7,700 applications as fraudulent or potentially fraudulent during the 2024-2025 academic year alone. That is a staggering number for any state system, and it shows this is not a handful of isolated cheaters slipping through the cracks.

Minnesota State pushed back hard on the headline figure. A spokesperson told FOX 9 the system never actually sent money to the bogus students and removed them from enrollment before any damage was done. That is a meaningful dispute. It means the public still does not know whether the $12.5 million reflects money actually lost, money attempted, or some broader measure of federal exposure.

Real Victims Are Left Holding The Bag

Behind the statistics are actual people whose names got hijacked. Jacob Rosenbacher says his identity was used without his knowledge to enroll at Normandale Community College and take out roughly $9,000 in federal student loans. He publicly blamed the school for not doing basic checks, saying all it would have taken was a quick Google search of his name.

Rosenbacher is not alone. Tony Rice said international criminals stole his identity, enrolled him in college, and applied for about $10,000 in loans in his name. A Minnesota State security official, Craig Munson, confirmed that fraudulent enrollments typically use stolen or fictitious identities, and that victims face a long slog correcting records and clearing their names.

This distinction matters. Some fraud involves entirely invented people who never existed. Other cases involve real Americans whose stolen Social Security numbers and names got hijacked by criminal rings. Lumping both groups under the label “ghost student” risks confusing the public about who the actual villain is here.

Congress Moves To Tighten The Front Door

Lawmakers are not waiting around for the numbers to get fully sorted out. The No Aid for Ghost Students Act would block colleges from disbursing federal aid to any applicant flagged for suspected identity fraud until that person verifies their identity in person or through live video. The House has already passed its version, and a Senate companion bill sits in committee.

Minnesota State is not sitting still either. The system received $3 million to build a new identity-verification system aimed at catching fake applicants before they ever reach a financial aid office. That money suggests state officials view this as a real and urgent operational problem, not just a political talking point from Washington.

Why The Numbers Still Do Not Add Up

Here is the honest problem. Federal officials say $12.5 million went out the door. Minnesota State says it did not. Nobody has released the underlying audit, the student-level files, or a methodology explaining how either side reached its number. Until that paperwork comes out, taxpayers are left choosing between two competing claims instead of one clear set of facts.

Common sense says both things can be partly true at once. Some of these 1,834 names may represent completely fabricated people who drained real federal dollars. Others may be stolen identities where the money got caught and reversed before real harm occurred. Sorting fraud rings from identity-theft victims is not a partisan exercise. It is basic due diligence that protects both taxpayers and innocent Americans caught in the crossfire.

Sources:

abcnews.com, congress.gov, govinfo.gov, normandale.edu